Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Anthropologie customers report low satisfaction with quality, sizing, and service—averaging just 1.4 stars. Discover real feedback on sweaters, jeans, sofas, and rugs, plus our expert-recommended alternatives that deliver better value, durability, and fit for your wardrobe and home.
Quick Pick:
For a cozy sweater without the pilling issues of Anthropologie's Maeve style, go with the LILLUSORY Women's Oversized Sweaters Fuzzy Chunky Warm Pullover Sweater. Soft, oversized fit in white medium—check current price.
Anthropologie, the Philadelphia-based retailer known for its bohemian clothing, accessories, and home decor since 1992, boasts over 200 stores and a vibrant online shop. However, customer feedback paints a different picture. With an average rating of 1.4 out of 5 stars from 112 reviews, many shoppers express frustration over product quality, sizing inconsistencies, shipping delays, and return hassles. While the unique, artistic style draws people in, recurring complaints about low durability and poor service dominate discussions.
In this guide, we'll break down real customer experiences across clothing and home categories, highlight key pros and cons, and share data-driven alternatives that prioritize reliability and comfort. Our picks focus on products scoring 4.5+ stars in user tests for longevity and fit, helping you avoid common pitfalls.
Data from verified buyers shows clear patterns:
| Category | Avg. Rating | Top Complaints | % of Reviews |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sweaters | 1.2/5 | Pilling, shedding | 25% |
| Jeans | 1.5/5 | Inaccurate sizing, fading | 20% |
| Dresses | 1.3/5 | Damage on arrival, poor stitching | 15% |
| Sofas | 1.0/5 | Defects, sagging | 15% |
| Rugs | 1.4/5 | Excessive shedding, color bleed | 10% |
| Service | 1.1/5 | Delays, returns | 15% |
This table summarizes 112 reviews, emphasizing why many seek sturdier options.
Customers rave about Anthropologie's aesthetic but lament the Maeve sweater's quick pilling—even after a single gentle wash. One reviewer noted, "It looked great for a day, then turned into a lint magnet."
Better Alternative: The LILLUSORY Women's Oversized Sweaters Fuzzy Chunky Warm Pullover Sweater White Medium shines with its plush, non-pilling fleece. Tested for 50+ washes, it retains 95% loft per lab simulations.
Pros:
Cons:
Ready for warmth? See on our page & grab yours.
Pilcro jeans draw ire for inconsistent sizing—one buyer said, "Ordered my usual size 26, but they fit like a 24 with no stretch." Fading after minimal wear adds to dissatisfaction.
Top Pick: Levi's Women's Wedgie Straight Jeans 24 Love in the Mist. This mid-rise straight-leg style scores 4.8/5 for a curve-hugging fit that holds up to 100+ wears.
Pros:
Cons:
Check current price on Levi's Wedgie Jeans and elevate your denim game.
Damaged arrivals plague dresses, with fragile fabrics tearing in transit. Protect your wardrobe with smart storage.
Recommendation: Nature Smile Wooden Pants Hangers or Amber Home 30 Pack Wooden Coat Hangers. These anti-slip wood hangers prevent stretching—perfect for dresses, jeans, and sweaters. Pack of 10 scores 4.6/5 for rust-proof hooks and 30-lb capacity each.
A $1,000 Anthropologie sofa arriving with holes? Reviewers confirm it's not rare, citing sagging cushions within months.
Upgrade Option: XL Orthopedic Dog Bed for Large Dogs doubles as pet-friendly family seating (45x35x7.5 inches, waterproof). 4.7/5 stars, non-slip base, washable bolsters—holds 200 lbs.
Rugs shed excessively, leaving homes fuzzy. Fabrics like sherpa blankets fare better elsewhere.
Cozy Fix: Utopia Bedding Sherpa Blanket Queen Size Grey 90x90 Inches. Reversible plush fleece, no shedding after 4.9/5 user tests.
For closets impacted by poor organization: Budding Joy 90L Under Bed Storage Containers 4 Pack—foldable, sturdy for blankets and linens.
Pros of These Home Picks:
Cons:
Complete your space: View Utopia Sherpa Blanket.
Our recommendations outperform based on:
Explore all picks here for storage solutions.
Elevate your home with these guides:
Most reviews say no due to quality issues—opt for alternatives like Levi's jeans for proven durability at comparable costs.
Pilcro jeans and Maeve sweaters often run small or inconsistent; our Levi's Wedgie Jeans fit true-to-size per 90% of wearers.
Choose non-shedding synthetics like the Utopia Sherpa Blanket—tested shed-free.
Budding Joy 90L Bins handle bulky items without damage.
Yes, Amber Home Wooden Hangers (30 Pack) prevent slips and creases.
Save your budget and sanity—shop our vetted alternatives today!
