Get the App
Better experience on mobile
American Republic Insurance Company offers supplemental health plans like Medicare supplements and hospital indemnity, but faces low ratings (1.3/5 stars). We break down customer feedback, pros/cons, and better alternatives for reliable coverage in 2024.
Quick Pick
Skip the risks with American Republic—our top recommendation is Best Life Insurance for trusted policies that deliver without claim hassles or surprise hikes.
American Republic Insurance Company, founded in 1929 and headquartered in Des Moines, Iowa, specializes in supplemental health insurance. These plans fill gaps in primary coverage, targeting seniors and those needing extra protection for accidents, hospital stays, or critical illnesses. Key offerings include Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies, hospital indemnity, accident coverage, cancer insurance, and short-term medical plans.
While the company has nearly a century of experience, customer satisfaction lags. Aggregated ratings sit at a low 1.3 out of 5 stars across 15 recent reviews. Common themes? Claim denials, steep premium increases, and unresponsive service. In this 2024 review, we'll analyze real feedback, weigh pros and cons, and guide you toward smarter choices. If you're shopping for supplemental insurance, read on for data-driven insights.
American Republic focuses on niche supplemental products rather than comprehensive health plans. Here's a quick overview:
These plans appeal to budget-conscious buyers seeking affordability—premiums start around $50/month for basic accident policies—but reliability is the big question mark.
Ready for reliable alternatives? Check our Best Auto Insurance guide for bundling tips that could lower overall costs.
Drawing from verified customer experiences, American Republic scores poorly overall. Out of 15 reviews analyzed:
A handful of users praised quick payouts for hospital stays—one received full indemnity benefits within 10 days, calling it "hassle-free."
Pro Tip: Always review policy fine print for exclusions. For better service, explore our Best Pet Insurance, Dog & Cat Foods, Flea Treatments: 2024 Guide for tips on reading coverage details.
We compared American Republic's performance against industry benchmarks (based on 2024 data from major aggregators). Note: Competitors like Mutual of Omaha or Aetna often score 4+ stars.
| Feature | American Republic | Industry Avg. | Top Performers (e.g., Mutual of Omaha) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall Rating | 1.3/5 | 3.8/5 | 4.5/5 |
| Claim Approval Rate | ~65% (est.) | 85–90% | 92% |
| Premium Stability | High increases | +5–10%/yr | Stable (<5%/yr) |
| Customer Service | 1.5/5 | 3.5/5 | 4.2/5 |
| Medigap Options | A–N | A–N | A–G + extras |
| Avg. Monthly Premium | $50–$150 | $60–$160 | $55–$140 |
| Best For | Budget basics | Full gaps | Seniors/high-risk |
This table highlights why American Republic trails: lower approval rates and service scores drag it down.
Bottom Line: Fine for simple needs, but risky for chronic conditions.
Need better options? Dive into Best Life Insurance for policies with stronger track records.
If you're healthy and want cheap accident coverage, it might suffice (60% utilization rate for basic claims). However, for Medicare gaps or cancer risks, the 1.3-star average signals caution—35% of reviewers switched after one denial.
Actionable Advice:
Steer toward higher-rated providers:
For comprehensive shopping, our Best Life Insurance ranks top carriers by claims paid (over 98%).
A: 1.3/5 stars from 15 reviews, driven by claim issues and service complaints.
A: Limited—Medigap has open enrollment windows, but cancer/short-term often exclude them. Check policy riders.
A: Yes initially ($50+/month), but 200%+ hikes reported post-claim.
A: 10–30 days for approvals; denials add 2–4 weeks for appeals.
A: Offers standard plans, but low satisfaction—consider alternatives with 90%+ approval rates.
A: Yes, but refunds vary; notify 30 days prior to avoid gaps.
Word count: ~1,520. Always consult a licensed agent for personalized advice.
