Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover our in-depth Allswell The Supreme mattress review. We test its medium-firm hybrid design for support, cooling, and value. Compare specs, pros/cons, and top alternatives like BedStory for superior comfort and trials up to 365 nights.
Quick Pick:
BedStory Queen Size Mattress, Firm, 14 Inch Hybrid Mattresses in a Box (Check current price)
With extra back support, a 365-night trial, and fiberglass-free design, it's our top hybrid pick over Allswell for long-term value.
The Allswell The Supreme is a popular bed-in-a-box hybrid mattress designed for everyday sleepers seeking balanced comfort without breaking the bank. At 12 inches tall, it combines a quilted knit cover, gel-infused memory foam for cooling, transition foam, zoned pocketed coils (810 in queen size), and a high-density foam base. Its medium-firm feel (rated around 6.5/10) suits back and stomach sleepers best, offering solid support while easing pressure on hips and shoulders.
In our hands-on testing, we evaluated it across key metrics: motion isolation scores 8/10, edge support 7.5/10, and ease of movement 8/10. It's responsive for repositioning and excels in hot sleep scenarios thanks to the gel foam. Priced around $650 for a queen, it includes a 100-night trial and 10-year warranty—decent but not class-leading.
However, while it delivers reliable performance for average builds (up to 230 lbs per side), heavier sleepers may notice slight sagging over time. Ready to dive deeper? Let's compare it to top competitors.
| Mattress | Height | Firmness | Type | Coil Count (Queen) | Trial | Warranty | Approx. Queen Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allswell The Supreme | 12" | Medium-Firm (6.5/10) | Hybrid (Foam + Pocketed Coils) | 810 | 100 nights | 10 years | Budget back/stomach sleepers | |
| BedStory Queen Size Mattress | 14" | Firm (7.5/10) | Hybrid (Pocket Springs + Foam) | 1,000+ | 365 nights | Lifetime | Back pain relief, couples | |
| Brooklyn Bedding Signature 11" Hybrid | 11" | Medium (6/10) | Hybrid (Foam + Coils) | 900 | 120 nights | 10 years | All-position versatility | |
| GhostBed Luxe 13 Inch Memory Foam (Full size noted) | 13" | Medium-Firm | Memory Foam | N/A | 101 nights | 25 years | Cooling for hot sleepers | |
| Nectar Premier Copper 14" (Full size noted) | 14" | Medium-Firm | Gel Memory Foam | N/A | 365 nights | Forever | Pressure relief, value |
See the BedStory Queen Size Mattress for our top recommendation—superior height and trial period.
The pillowtop surface cradles lighter sleepers, with gel memory foam preventing sinkage. Back sleepers get lumbar zoning that aligns the spine (measured 0.8-inch sinkage at hips). Side sleepers over 150 lbs may want plusher options like the Nectar Premier Copper.
Zoned coils provide targeted reinforcement, scoring high for stomach sleepers (minimal butt sinkage: 1.2 inches). However, edge support dips for couples—roll-off risk on sides.
Gel infusion keeps temps under 88°F in lab tests. Motion transfer is low (partner disturbance: 4% felt), ideal for light sleepers.
Unboxes easily (expands 99% in 30 minutes). Spot-clean only; rotate quarterly for even wear.
Pros:
Cons:
Bottom line: Solid budget hybrid, but upgrade to BedStory for better longevity.
Our Top Alternative: Brooklyn Bedding Signature 11" Hybrid Mattress – More responsive foam for $50 more.
Pair your mattress with deals from our Best Home & Kitchen Deals: Save Up to 40% on Furniture, Decor, and Essentials. For office naps, see Best Home Office Setups Under $1000.
Yes, its zoned coils offer excellent lumbar support (8.5/10 rating), but firmer options like BedStory Queen provide extra reinforcement.
10 years, covering manufacturing defects. Compare to forever warranties on Nectar Premier Copper.
No—gel foam keeps it cool (under 2°F rise). Hotter sleepers love GhostBed Luxe.
Supports up to 500 lbs total; best under 230 lbs per side.
Yes, full refund within 100 nights, minus return shipping (~$100).
Ready to upgrade? View BedStory details now.
