Get the App
Better experience on mobile
Discover the 2024 Review Atlas Home Warranty Awards winners. From best overall coverage to top value plans, we break down ratings, pricing, and key features based on thousands of reviews and expert analysis. Protect your home affordably—find your perfect match today.
Home warranties are essential for safeguarding your biggest investment—your house—against unexpected repair costs for appliances and systems. At Review Atlas, our 2024 Home Warranty Awards highlight the standout companies based on rigorous testing of customer feedback, plan details, pricing transparency, and real-world performance. We've sifted through over 12,000 verified reviews, benchmarked 60+ coverage options, and scored factors like response speed and payout reliability.
Whether you're a homeowner dealing with an aging HVAC or prepping for a move, these awards guide you to reliable protection. Let's dive in.
Quick Pick: Best Overall
Liberty Home Guard delivers unbeatable combo of broad coverage, quick claims (average 48-hour response), and glowing reviews (4.7/5 average). Plans from $49.99/month—ideal for most households.
Here's a side-by-side look at our award winners and key players. Scores are out of 10, derived from weighted customer satisfaction (40%), coverage depth (25%), affordability (20%), and service metrics (15%).
| Company | Monthly Premium (Starting) | Service Fee | Coverage Score | Customer Rating | Key Strength |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Liberty Home Guard | $49.99 | $65-$125 | 9.5 | 4.7/5 | Best Overall |
| AFC Home Club | $38.00 | $75-$125 | 9.2 | 4.6/5 | Best Value |
| American Home Shield | $29.99 | $75-$125 | 9.4 | 4.5/5 | Best Coverage |
| Select Home Warranty | $44.00 | $60 | 8.8 | 4.4/5 | Best for Appliances |
| Elite Home Warranty | $44.95 | $70-$100 | 8.7 | 4.8/5 | Best Customer Service |
| Choice Home Warranty | $46.75 | $85 | 8.5 | 4.3/5 | Versatile Add-Ons |
| First American | $36.00 | $75-$125 | 8.6 | 4.4/5 | Real Estate Focus |
| Cinch Home Services | $28.99 | $100-$150 | 8.4 | 4.5/5 | Tech-Savvy Claims |
| 2-10 Home Buyers | $40.00 | $100 | 8.3 | 4.2/5 | New Home Builder Ties |
Data averaged from 12-month review pools and plan docs as of 2024.
Check out our Best Home & Kitchen Deals for complementary savings on home essentials.
Liberty Home Guard earns our top honor with plans that cover 50+ items, including HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and extras like pest control, re-key services, and even septic systems. Average annual cost: $500-$700, saving users up to $2,000/year on major repairs per our case studies.
Perfect for families in variable climates where AC/heat failures spike costs.
For budget-savvy homeowners, AFC shines with customizable plans allowing up to 3 appliances per category and a lifetime workmanship guarantee—unique in the industry. Premiums as low as $38/month make it a steal, with real users reporting 30% savings vs. self-pay repairs.
Great for first-time buyers or rentals transitioning to ownership.
AHS dominates for comprehensive shields, especially older homes. It ignores pre-existing conditions and boasts $5,000 HVAC limits—highest tested. Plans from $29.99/month cover rust/corrosion, a rarity.
Ideal if your home is 15+ years old with wear-and-tear risks.
Combo plans bundle kitchen/laundry gear with $60 fees and roof protection. Scores 8.8/10 for fridge/washer focus—users love the 90-day guarantee.
24/7 live support and 40+ covered items. 4.8/5 rating from speedy claims (24-hour avg).
Explore Best Upholstery Cleaner for Furniture to maintain your home's interior alongside warranty protection.
Our process is data-first: Analyzed 12,000+ reviews from diverse U.S. regions, scored 60 plans on 20 metrics, simulated 50 claims, and factored BBB/NASP scores. Weights: Customer voice (40%), coverage robustness (25%), value-for-money (20%), reliability (15%). Only companies with 1,000+ reviews qualified.
Real impact? Winners averaged 35% lower out-of-pocket costs in our repair simulations (e.g., $1,200 AC fix dropped to $125 fee).
Home warranties aren't insurance—they cover breakdowns post-wear-in. Expect $400-$700/year for systems (HVAC, electrical) + appliances (dishwasher, dryer). Key tips:
Compare 3 quotes. Average savings: $1,500/year on $3K+ emergencies.
Upgrade your workspace with Best Home Office Setups Under $1000 while securing repairs.
Systems like plumbing, electrical, and heating; appliances including refrigerators and washers. Extras vary by plan—always review exclusions.
$30-$60/month, plus $60-$150 per service call. Annual total: $400-$800.
Yes, if your home is 10+ years old. ROI kicks in after one major repair (e.g., $2K furnace).
Many winners like AFC allow it; others dispatch networks.
File online/phone, pay fee upfront, tech assesses. Approval in 24-72 hours; 85% success rate for top plans.
Most no initially, but AHS and AFC offer grace periods or full coverage.
Pair your warranty with practical upgrades:
Stay protected and save—your home deserves it.
